YouTube and Downloading?
In early September EDNA’s Blogging Corner’s forum debated the legalities of downloading YouTube videos because it’s a violation of YouTube’s terms of service to download.
So I was intrigued that Simon and Matthieu information on YouTube states that:
A copy of a YouTube video may be downloaded under section 28 of the Australian Copywrite act provided that the copy is made solely for educational purposes and the YouTube video is not an infringing copy.
Which motivated me to do some detective work!
Australian Copyright Council
First stop the Australian Copyright Council site on legal issues of use of YouTube in Education and teaching.
It does state under certain conditions under the Section 200AB of the Copyright Act can allow an educational institution to download a YouTube video without infringing copyright. I especially like the part that says if you haven’t read the Terms of Conditions and accepted their Terms of Conditions by signing up with YouTube then their conditions are unlikely to be legally binding on you.
Australia’s Smartcopying site
Next I checked Australia’s Smartcopying site which provides a more detailed discussion on Teacher’s use of YouTube. This site explains that the Flexible Dealing Exception of Section 200AB of the Copyright Act may allow the YouTube video to be copied. But it also states that each educational jurisdiction will need to make their own decision on what is permitted by the Copyright Act in light of YouTube’s terms and conditions.
What does this mean? You need to contact your Local Copyright Manager because interpretation may vary between Government and Non-Government schools in each Australian State or Territory. Here are the recommendations for Western Australia.
Safest bet is to make your own decision based on the most accurate information. Also remember that Copyright laws vary considerably between countries.
Image by Jonsson under Creative Commons License.
And if you’re enjoying this blog, please consider Subscribing for free!
9 thoughts on “YouTube and Downloading?”
Thanks Sue, it’s always reassuring to have copyright explained as it can be confusing at times. Just wondering why the comment above states (it is spam): WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP (220.127.116.11) doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP () and so is spam.
@Marie I think copyright is totally confusing. It’s definitely made easier when people use creative commons but otherwise we are left dealing with grey areas.
Unfortunately at the moment all pingback (where someone links to your post) have the WordPress Hashcash comment added below the pingback. I could remove but that becomes quite a lengthy process.
copyrihgt is very confusing but this is only my though and cool blog by the way oh yea one more thing sorry but you got the riddle wrong =]
@Herky Definitely confusing and I’m definitely going to get one of your riddles right eventually.
Thank you for the comment it was very
nice. I wish i could ride to school on
my pony but i go on the bus to school
and it would be pretty far to ride. Well hope
you come and visit my blog again.
In this situation the rules are so lacking in clarity that it seems to me perfectly reasonable to go ahead without fear of recrimination or trouble sleeping at night.
@Zoe No problem enjoyed visiting your blog.
@Steve Collis I’m with you. It is murky and confusing.